Across Ontario thousands of students have faced suspensions from school under the Immunization of School Pupils Act (ISPA) due to incomplete vaccination records.
In Hamilton, 1,252 students were suspended, while Windsor-Essex saw 618 secondary and 129 elementary students excluded. Toronto issued notices to over 10,000 students, starting suspensions with 173 Grade 11 students on April 8, and Waterloo Region suspended 1,624 elementary students.
The ISPA mandates up-to-date immunization records, required vaccines, or valid exemptions for medical, religious, or conscientious reasons. Non-compliance results in suspensions, sparking significant debate over students’ and parents’ rights to bodily autonomy and privacy.
The enforcement of these policies has led to notable disruptions in students’ education, with suspensions lasting until compliance is achieved. Parents are required to provide proof of vaccination or navigate a complex exemption process, which includes submitting detailed paperwork and, in some cases, attending mandatory education sessions.
Critics argue this framework undermines bodily autonomy by pressuring families to vaccinate, even when they hold philosophical or conscientious objections. The absence of a centralized, digitized immunization registry exacerbates privacy concerns, as families are required to repeatedly disclose sensitive medical information to schools and public health units, raising fears of data mishandling.
Public health officials defend the measures, citing the need to protect community health amid low vaccination rates linked to the measles outbreak, with 661 reported cases by April. However, the heavy-handed approach has drawn criticism for prioritizing compliance over individual rights.
The exemption process, while available, is often seen as bureaucratic, potentially deterring families from exercising their legal options. This has fueled perceptions of coercion, particularly among parents who feel their autonomy and their children’s right to education are being compromised.
Recent updates from local news agencies indicate progress in resolving suspensions. While there is no way to discern how many were resolved by vaccination versus successful exemption submissions, by April 24, Waterloo Region reported only 70 elementary students remained suspended, down from 1,624. Ottawa reduced its suspension list to 60 students after issuing 15,000 notices. In Hamilton, fewer than 400 students were still missing records by May, and Toronto Public Health anticipated over 90% compliance, suggesting most students have returned to school after updating records or securing exemptions. In Waterloo however, secondary students face potential suspensions after a May 7 deadline, indicating ongoing issues.
The clash between public health mandates and individual liberties remains central. While public health units offer clinics and tools like the Immunization Connect Ontario system to facilitate compliance, the policy’s enforcement continues to raise questions about balancing community safety with students’ right to education and parents’ rights to make medical decisions for their children.
We continue to advocate for our Charter rights – for bodily autonomy and an individual’s right to choose, over the overreach of bureaucratic policy. These complex exemption process only adds to the coercive efforts to undermine a parent’s ability to take charge of their child’s health and well-being.
Every parent should have the right to make these choices with ease and without coercion.
To access vaccine exemption forms on the Mama Bears website, click here
